Learning to let go: The fifth step in Tuckman cycle

Thursday May 16th, 2019 0 comments

You probably all heard about a classic in team dynamics, called the Tuckman cycle: When assembling, a team (even a couple of people) tends to start with a stage called “Forming” (socialisation, need for inclusion), then it will naturally migrate towards “Storming” (affirmation, assertiveness), followed by “Norming” (reflecting, structuring and learning from the previous mistakes) and finally “Performing” which is what the leader and shareholders were longing for.

To this very predictable cycle (which I better explained in a recent post) we added a fifth step, often overlooked: Deforming, which is the necessary to take in order to healthily close a project, period of time together or relationship.

Recently, I was deeply disappointed with what appears to be the end of a relationship with a client we served for more than ten years. Disappointment and sadness (“after all we’ve done for them”) were the emerging feelings until one of my partners in the US sent me the mail here below which is a perfect illustration of what “De-Forming” is about and should be lived as. I thought worth bringing his reflection to your knowledge as I found it relevant for business ties and other personal relationships.

“Dids (my nickname with some of my partners),

These incidents are always troubling.  I’m never sure what really happened, who I p… off, who got jealous, who got tired of me or what I was doing, who was too scared to push the envelope and I ended up taking the blame, who I didn’t pay enough attention to or who fell in love with someone else.

Over the years we’ve watched this dynamic and, with some long term clients, we have seen an arc to the relationship: someone really likes what we do, we come in and do it, others like it and resonate and we start working more broadly or more strategically, we help them achieve great success … then it starts to wane… my sense is that at some point, we have given our gift, they have enjoyed it and the ride, and now it’s time for them to move on.  Of course we can refresh and reinvigorate our approach and offering and sometimes that buys us another chapter or two.  Ultimately the players change or they move on.  We may stay connected to those execs that see us as trusted partners, but the big work is gone. Sometimes these things just sputter out or diminish into the twilight, other times people say hurtful things in the ending.  I’ve reflected a lot on this since I tend to be all in with my clients, and many become friends as we spend a lot of time together.  In many cases what becomes apparent is that friendship is contextual – we’re together a lot, the exchanges are real …, yet the reason we’re together is that we have business to transact, a job to do.  When they decide that the job is over, I’ve never had anyone say: “Hey, we’ve had a really amazing ride, we’ve supported each other and had lots of fun together over the years, it’s now time for me to move on (for whatever reason) and I want to acknowledge that.  It’s not that I don’t hold you in high regard, or like who you are, or value our relationship, it’s just time to move on.  There may be other ways for us to work together going forward, but for now… and I recognize that we also have a personal connection”.

When this happens, it hurts … like a break up or divorce in some measure. Part of my gift with my clients is not only how I help them achieve their goals, but that I care about them, and in cases where we got close over time, I genuinely like them.  And yet, in these cases our relationship began as a business transaction and ends as a business transaction.  The fact that we built a strong connection with them is less relevant at the end of the day than the business purpose.  on rare occasions the personal remains after the business relationship is done – and for those I’m grateful.”

Taking the Call to Adventure, transforming ourselves, falling and recovering are vivid parts of our leadership Journey. Enjoy it!


  • “Be the bird” by Hamilton Mann

    Thursday May 9th, 2019 0 comments

    Hamilton Mann is the Group Director, Digital Marketing and Digital Transformation at Thales, an 80’000 people French multinational I came across this article he recently wrote on the topic of innovation. The reason to republish it, with his consent, is that, exactly the same applies when it comes to Transformation, Change & Disruptive thinking. I really encourage you to read…

    Read the full article →

  • Am I a stone carver or a Cathedral builder?

    Thursday May 2nd, 2019 0 comments

    I work a lot with the themes of Purpose and Deep Intent. A few days ago, I came across a very interesting Cassie Werber’s article dedicated to the same topic. Putting the record straight, INSEAD professor Gianpiero Petriglieri claims that, if it is fundamental to give meaning to our work, we shouldn’t expect anybody else to do it for us:…

    Read the full article →

  • You never will be too empathetic!

    Friday April 19th, 2019 0 comments

    Recently, Korn-Ferry published an article about feedback, which was quickly interpreted by some as “too much empathy isn’t good!”. My reply to one of them was that, after 35 years of professional life, I was still expecting to find anyone loaded with too much empathy! As a leader, no one will ever demonstrate too much empathy! Empathy elicit outstanding contribution…

    Read the full article →

  • Don’t waste your time communicating: ENGAGE!

    Friday April 12th, 2019 4 comments

    So many leaders still assume that the job has been done, once their Convention, webcast or confcall ended-up well! The Communication Pack is ready; the new Strategy, Vision, Organization or Roadmap has been explained and everyone will now cascade it, supported by a professional communication team… “Mission accomplished”, do the leaders feel by leaving the room. This is what happened…

    Read the full article →

  • If you wish to bring radical change, avoid taking the wrong start!

    Friday April 5th, 2019 4 comments

    All of you, whom I had the chance to work for, probably remember this simple and elegant matrix, inherited from my leadership Professor and ex-partner, Chris Parker: The Challenge vs Support matrix. It represents the different sorts of culture that leaders create through using none, one or both of the Challenge (demanding, dare) and Support (benevolence, care) levers. As you…

    Read the full article →

  • Shapership: The Art of Shaping the Future (Part II)

    Saturday March 30th, 2019 0 comments

    Aline Frankfort and Jean-Louis Baudoin are the founders of Creative Consulteam, a boutique consultancy in Creative Leadership. Summarizing their observations about leaders who manage to create a culture of innovation, they came up with the concept of “Shapership”.  This article is the 2nd part of the one published last week. Shapership is this capacity to Shape the Future and inspire…

    Read the full article →

  • Shapership: The Art of Shaping the Future (Part I)

    Wednesday March 20th, 2019 0 comments

    Aline Frankfort and Jean-Louis Baudoin are the founders of Creative Consulteam, a boutique consultancy in Creative Leadership. Summarizing their observations about leaders who manage to create a culture of innovation, they came up with the concept of “Shapership”, which they explain in this article and the following one next week. I thank them for sharing it here. What we introduce…

    Read the full article →

  • When your team drifts to “benevolent neutrality”, try “Positive Abrasion”

    Thursday February 28th, 2019 0 comments

    A friend of mine leads a team of 25 top professionals, recognizable by their strong egos. His main frustration was that a sort of “Paradox of Friendship” (following an old study at Bell Labs which found that, in many project teams, creativity and performance were plummeting 12 to 16 months after the team had been assembled, due to its members…

    Read the full article →

  • Your boss should change and you should stop being a consenting victim!

    Friday February 22nd, 2019 2 comments

    As I explained in a recent blogpost, there are no options for us: If we want to be credible transformational leaders, the guarantee that our people expect is to see us “put skin in the game” and suffer with them. And our suffering has one name: Spectacularly change something in our behaviour! Fabio Celestini was elected 2016 football coach of…

    Read the full article →

  • Our people need Exemplarity, not Perfection!

    Saturday February 2nd, 2019 12 comments

    Each time I meet a CEO or other high-ranking Officer, who’s had the insight that the Disruption Economy requires her organization to transform itself and wants it NOW, my question comes as early as it can in the dialogue: “How badly do you want this change to take place? It is not just a matter of strategy, processes or organization.…

    Read the full article →