If you must provoke a radical turnaround… Try benevolence!

June 25, 2015 5 comments

Often, when parachuted into a turnaround situation, we face a bit of a dilemma: Do I “shake my people up” or do I comfort them?

A first surprising experience of leadership as a ski instructor (for those of you who know me now, it is inconceivable that I once had long hair and was nicknamed “Jesus”), came by trying to encourage a GM top executive to let go of his fear  and ski down a very light beginners’ slope. He just couldn’t. He was petrified. I then thought: “I’ll try to take his fear over”. So I screamed loud at him and he suddenly moved. 10 seconds later, he turned with a wonderful smile made of pride and relief: “Gee, for a second I got more scared by you than by this mountain… Thank you!” And he became a very decent skier.

sc0001c32eMe in my “Ski Instructor phase” 30 years ago ;)

We all know about those determined leaders, cutting costs, axing jobs, uninterested by being popular or loved. They usually are celebrated for saving their companies (sometimes at a high cost) and shape up the business school collective unconscious. Even an old model such as the 60’s “Situational Leadership” recommends we use the “Telling style” (directive, task focus) when followers seem unprepared for the challenge they are confronted with and that the situation is alarming. So, there sometimes is merit in choosing a driving, at times “fear inspiring” approach in extreme situations, when the team looks paralysed.

However, fear always carries a price tag: “Even if we insist on obedience, we will never gain it for long, and only at the cost of what we wanted the most : loyalty, intelligence and responsiveness” wrote M. Wheatley & M. Kellner-Rogers in 1998. Studies of the impact of fear on the human brain (already quoted in a previous post, in 2009) confirm that:

  • The reptilian brain constantly checks our surroundings and stays alert to potential threats to our Survival (losing my job in corporate terms), our Territory (my department, budget, team, my ego and pride in business terms) and our Habits (talk about Change Management?)
  • If such a threat is perceived, a signal is sent to our limbic brain which triggers an immediate defence mechanism: Fight (argue, criticize, attack, disagree…), Flight (avoid, pretend, bow down…) or Freeze (no initiative, petrified…). Decency prohibits me to quote the fourth “F”…
  • These defence mechanisms “switch off” our Neo-Cortex, where reside our capacities to reflect, analyse, decide, be creative and innovative…

A leader seeking to engage his organization, to get his people to think “out of the box”, or take measured risks, will be at a loss when wielding the axe. People will be in a completely defensive/passive mode or will rebel and leave.

I recently had the chance to observe three leaders who chose a radically different approach. All were given difficult business situations, demanding a rapid and decisive turnaround. They chose benevolence rather than fear, challenge and threats, to start with. This is what they had in common:

  • Unconditional support: They decided to “kill the fear” rather than “killing people”. They reassured, listened, celebrated past accomplishment, by showing respect for the precedent although not always successful efforts.
  • Clear & demanding expectations: They made it clear however that their expectation was nothing less than a radical turn around and that they were there to save and reinvent the company. They navigated smoothly between challenge and support, between being very demanding and simply benevolent.
  • Usage of symbols: they mastered the art of leading through emotions (Pathos). They wisely used symbols (refurbishing the offices, abolishing unnecessary procedures hindering creativity), gestures (their style was inviting, their door always opened, they drastically reduced the distance between leaders and followers) and collected and propagated credible, authentic and positive stories.

For many around them, they were betting on the wrong horse: How can you invest into repainting the building when we are bleeding cash? People need a solid shake-up etc. But they firmly held on to their approach. In one case, the miraculous turnaround already happened, and he has now been sent to fix another bigger problem. For another, the project (the most ambitious ever for this 90’000 + employees organization) that was at risk, has been successful transformed and the third has just started but to see the passion, faith, hope and respect in the eyes of his team, I bet they are on the right path

In an age where complexity and chaos are part of the leadership context, by which leaders have to be decisive even when they don’t know the answers (What Denys Monteiro in an excellent article calls Waze leaders, as opposed to GPS leaders) benevolent leaders, because they are capable of harnessing the loyalty, collaborative, creative and entrepreneurial “juices” of their people, go further and longer than their fear inspiring counterparts.

  • Get rid of your “superstars”!

    June 20, 2015 2 comments

    This morning, actuality came knocking on the door of this blog, which explains why it is posted later than usual. The news is irrelevant in the context of the existing horrors and gigantic economic and environmental challenges. But in the microcosm of football, I read that Brazil, engaged into the Copa America, will have to do, once again, without their…

    Read the full article →

  • Der Weg ist das Ziel! How to create an impactful statement

    June 13, 2015 2 comments

    Last week’s post has attracted a lot of attention and numerous comments (almost all private, given the level most of you operate at). A consensus seems to emerge: A Vision/Mission/Strategic/Values Statement  cannot be reduced to a simple communication exercise. Nevertheless, we often fall into the trap of thinking that the elaboration of an almost perfect statement, and its subsequent communication…

    Read the full article →

  • No company ever became visionary through a vision statement!

    June 5, 2015 2 comments

    Built to last, the book from Stanford professors James Collins and Jerry Porras has been a revelation for millions of students, academics and executives, since its publication in 1994. It has since lost a part of its credibility (see this article in Fast Company), as many of the companies it described as sustainable (built to last) seem to have met…

    Read the full article →

  • Wish to evaluate your ability to engage followers? Take the handrail test

    May 28, 2015 2 comments

    As the novelist, who knows the nightmare of facing, without the slightest inspiration, a desperately white sheet for hours, the business leader sometimes fears this Moment of Truth, when he will have to engage his organization in an apparently dull, unspectacular but necessary challenge. That is why HSE, sustainability, compliance, risk, quality, excellence, innovation, diversity and others often remain buzzwords,…

    Read the full article →

  • Hollywood and Military know how to engage their organizations in the Disruption Economy

    May 22, 2015 2 comments

    Recently, I saw been delivered a fascinating session explaining to business executives, how professional troops were operating, under extreme conditions, when disruption and unexpected changes were the rules of the game. speaker explained that under such conditions, the old “Command & Control” was totally inefficient and illusory, given the fact that people in operations needed to react faster than their…

    Read the full article →

  • Diversity is endangered by the politically correct!

    May 15, 2015 14 comments

    In our network, we count 9 wemen (out of 35), 1 Algerian, 4 Americans, 1 Australian, 3 Belgians, 5 Brazilians, 7 British, 3 Canadians, 1 Congolese, 1 Dutch, 9 French, 1 German, 1 Lebanese, 1 Swede, 3 Swiss (yes it counts more than 35 as we have double nationals) and we are based in Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, France, Honk-Kong,…

    Read the full article →

  • Your feedback and creativity are needed

    May 8, 2015 16 comments

    In the recent months, still positively influenced by Nokia’s “Connecting People” way of life and belief, I happened to match executives needing to change horizon with clients looking for the rare bird. And it seems to have been happy marriages. In each of the cases, our clients informally had turned to us, as they were unimpressed by the solution or…

    Read the full article →

  • “Insuring your costly acquisition against failure”

    May 1, 2015 0 comments

    Merging or acquiring are two highly risky decisions to take. Following several consultancies, the proportion of such operations, failing to deliver on their promises, is around 70%. Why do we get it so wrong? A paper, to which some of us contributed, brought interesting ideas forward: Jeffrey Krug in a 2009 HBR article pointed out that “The managers in charge…

    Read the full article →

  • How can I change my behaviour?

    April 24, 2015 6 comments

    Those of you who we work for, know that we use a lot the three levers of engagement (named after Aristotle famous “modes of persuasion” or rhetorical strategies): Logos (the clarity/sanity test): The intellectual lever, absolutely vital, creator of energy. People will not follow nor engage behind a leader who lacks intellectual clarity. Ethos (the credibility test): People don’t listen…

    Read the full article →

  • “It is astonishing to see how many of the behaviors we fear in one another dissipate in the presence of good relationship”

    April 18, 2015 4 comments

    Part of our practice is to be discretely flown somewhere, in an emergency mission, in order to help diffuse the dramatic effect of the falling apart between members of a leadership team. I remember being called by the Chairman of the Board and being requested to take a flight in another part of the world, to discretely meet the CEO,…

    Read the full article →